Showing posts with label communication. Show all posts
Showing posts with label communication. Show all posts

Monday, May 28, 2018

Bill Miller's Book, "Listening Well" is Worth a Post, and Read

It's been about a year and a half since I last posted here. I can't tell you why I have lapsed, though I have been preoccupied with work, my family and current events. All have contributed to the challenge of staying "posted" on developments in the world of empathy.

Plus, Ed Rutsch and his sites, Center for Building a Culture for Empathy, and Empathy and HealthCare are both awesome and comprehensive sources for posts and developments.

It was actually a post by Ed on Culture for Empathy that featured Bill Miller and his new book, Listening Well: The Art of Empathic Understanding that stimulated me to resume blogging and write this post.

Bill Miller is the primary force behind Motivational Interviewing, a highly effective motivational counseling method that features an empathic patient-centered style. I highly recommend Bill's little new book, which serves as a primer on the core empathic listening skills that are central elements of MI. There is so much wisdom in this little book, as well as great examples of empathic listening and valuable suggestions for skill practice.

Enjoy!


Sunday, July 6, 2014

More Strategies for Expressing and Teaching Empathy


In a previous EmpathyWorks blog post, I addressed the question, "Can you actually teach empathy?".  As i noted in the column, the answer is a resounding, "Yes!" , at least for medical students and health care professionals.
Research has demonstrated that courses like, "The Healer's Art", (see: The Healer's Art webpage),  developed by Rachel Remen at the University of California San Francisco, profiled in EmpathyWorks, and also in a New York Time feature article, are effective in promoting humanistic attitudes and practices among medical students.  
Rachel Remen
And  there is strong evidence that skill training and practice can promote patient-centered skills, including empathy, among practicing clinicians. (See:.http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23235595)

Motivational Interviewing skills were featured in my previous post on strategies for teaching empathy. 

Another strategy for helping students and clinicians learn how to respond with empathy has been disseminated by Robert C. Smith, MD and colleagues at Michigan State University. The approach, NURS,  is a mnemonic that stands for Name, Understand, Respect and Support. This approach is described in detail in Dr. Smith's textbook, Patient-Centered Interviewing. You can also read an recent article on this approach in the medical journal, Patient Education and Counseling: 

See below for a modified version of the NURS approach, NURSE. The E is for Empower
  • Name the emotion - reflect what you heard or noticed non-verbally. 
          Examples include:

      • "You feel frustrated..."
      • "You're angry....".
      • "You seem pretty sad..." 
  •  Understand  - express understanding, or normalize, without trying to fix
           Examples include:

      • "It's understandable that you are frustrated, considering all you have been through."
      • "I  can understand you why you would be angry about...."
      • "Many of my patients have experienced deep sadness for a long time after losing a loved one."
      • "I think I can understand how distressing this has been for you."
  • Respect - affirm and express respect for the patient's efforts to cope 
          Examples include:

      • "I'm impressed with your efforts to manage your diabetes, despite the challenges"
      • "It's remarkable that you were able to.....".
      • "I appreciate how hard this has been for you..." 
      • "Thanks for letting me know"
  • Support - let the patient know that you are willing to help 
          Examples include:

      • "I want to help in any way I can."
      • "I am here for you."
      • "I am willing to help you get through this".
      • "I will work with you to figure out a way to help." (Some educators call this "Partnership")
      • "Let's work together to address your concerns" (Some educators call this "Partnership")
      • "What can i do to help?"  (Asking this question reflects your willingness to explore how you might be helpful)
  • Empower - identify and support strengths and capabilities
          Examples include:

      • "What are you currently doing that is helping?"
      • "What have you done in the past that has been helpful?"
      • "What success have you had?" 
      • When strategies are mentioned: "It's good that you have been able to xx"
      • "How can you build on previous success?"
      • "What else can you do?"
      • "Who can help you?"
      • "What can i do to support you?
      • When resources are identified: "You have been able to identify some helpful resources and sources of support."
As always, i am interested in hearing about your feedback and in learning about your favorite strategies for teaching empathy.

Sunday, April 6, 2014

Strategies for Expressing Empathy

"So you think you can actually teach empathy to doctors?"
This is a question I have been asked scores of times during my 30+ years as a a medical educator.

And my answer is:
"Yes, it is possible to teach empathy to clinicians, even doctors."
Though many students, and practicing clinicians, are naturally empathic, and express empathy consistently during encounters with patients, others need help identifying how to respond to patients' expressed emotions, values and concerns, both verbally and non-verbally. And many others, though fully capable of responding effectively, have learned to suppress their natural empathic responses, both consciously and unconsciously, during training. Researchers have shown that the rigors of training and its intense focus on acquiring biomedical knowledge and skills can erode humanistic attitudes and practices. (See Rabin MW, Remen RN, Parmaelee DX and Inui TS. Professional Formation: Extending Medicine's Lineage of Service into the Next Century. Academic Medicine: 2010; 85:310 - 317. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20107361)

For those who need help in learning how to express empathy, research has shown that skill training and practice (with feedback) can help, even among "seasoned" practicing clinicians. (See Dwamena, FM, Holmes-Rovner, et al. (2012). "Interventions for providers to promote a patient-centred approach in clinical consultations." Cochrane Database Syst Rev 12: CD003267. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23235595)

Though a single communications skills workshop is not a sufficient "dose" of training for most learners, providing opportunities for repeated learning and practice can help many clinicians to adopt and regularly employ empathic skills in their interactions with patients, especially if personalized feedback is offered in the context of a supportive learning environment.
So,how do you teach empathy?
In my teaching, I have found the following strategies to be particularly valuable. They can help clinicians "find the words" to use when opportunities arise in encounters with patients.
Open-ended questions help the clinician explore and elicit the patients feelings, concerns, values or beliefs. Here are some examples:
  • How are you holding up?
  • What has this been like for you?
  • Tell me more about how you are feeling.
  • What else have you been experiencing?
  • How has this impacted your…..(relationships, condition, work, school, life)
  • Tell me more about what this means to you.
When a patient expresses an emotion, value or belief, (either spontaneously, or in response to a query),  the clinician may respond with a "reflection" that reiterates what the patient has said, either in the patient's own words, or with an approximation. 

Reflections (with "stems" to help form the reflections)

  • I can see you are ..…(upset, sad, frustrated, worried, anxious, distressed, angry, etc.)
  • You seem ..…(upset, sad, frustrated, worried, anxious, distressed, angry, etc.
  • I hear you saying that you feel.(upset, sad, frustrated, worried, anxious, angry, etc.)
  • Sounds like it’s been ….(.upsetting, depressing, frustrating, worrisome, nerve- wracking,  distressing, maddening, awful, etc.)
Reflections (without stems)
  • You are…(upset, sad, frustrated, worried, anxious, distressed, angry, etc.)
  • It’s been…(upsetting, depressing, frustrating, worrisome, maddening, awful, etc.)
  • This is important to you…
After a reflection, WAIT to allow the person to correct, confirm, elaborate, continue. (This is challenging for many clinicians who want to follow a reflection with a question)
Affirmations (with genuineness) are a type of reflection that also recognizes the patient's efforts or achievements. Patients generally appreciate this. 
  • You put a lot of effort into this….
  • You have worked so hard on this….· 
“Non-verbal” responses·
  • Eye contact
  • Sitting down, leaning in, moving closer,
  • Nodding, verbal facilitation (“oh”, “hmm”, “uhh”, “gosh”)
  • Matching (reflecting non-verbal gestures, without mimicking)
  • Touch, when appropriate
These strategies are featured in Motivational Interviewing (MI), an evidence-based clinical method that promotes partnership, acceptance, compassion and an evoking (as opposed to directing style). See my favorite links or go directly to: http://www.motivationalinterview.org/ for more information, tools and resources on using MI.

What are your favorite strategies for helping others to express empathy?


Saturday, December 28, 2013

A Short Video on Empathy Featuring Brené Brown


Sue Raffa, PhD, a colleague at Alpert Medical School, Brown University,  recently shared a wonderful animated video on empathy with me. The brief video was created by the Royal Society of the Arts (RSA) and features Brene Brown, PhD, LMSW, a research professor at the University of Houston Graduate Colleage of Social Work.

You can find the video at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1Evwgu369Jw

The video offers a wonderful, quick,and amusing lesson on empathy and how if differs from sympathy. 

I particularly like Dr. Brown's  reference to the 4 key qualities of empathy:

  1. perspective taking
  2. staying out of judgement
  3. recognizing emotion; and
  4. communicating what you notice


I also like her idea that empathy "fuels connection", contrasted with sympathy, which "drives disconnection". Empathy, she states, can be operationalized as "feeling with" other and requires a "vulnerable choice". She adds, "To connect with you, I have to connect with something in myself that knows that feeling", which can be painful. Empathy, she notes, is not about trying to make things better, it's about being present and expressing understanding to a person who is struggling>

"Rarely can a response make something better....what makes something better is connection."

Awesome! 

Tuesday, October 1, 2013

Danielle Ofri's Reflections on Fear Triggered by Illness

Danielle Ofri's recent column on Slate, the online magazine, addresses the topic of fear that results from uncertainty and the risks associated with medical illnesses and procedures, even minor ones. Danielle shares the distress and acute fear she experienced as a mom when her young son required minor ear surgery. Even though, as a physician, she understood that the risk of the procedure was low, she nonetheless imagined the worst and became gripped with raw fear that  didn't abate till her son was fully recovered from his surgery.

Dr. Ofri's distress during that minor ordeal increased her awareness of the needs of her patients and their family for her  support, empathy and compassion during episodes of illness, especially when tough medical decisions need to be made. As Danielle points out, the process of shared decision making requires more than information sharing and collaboration. It also requires eliciting and responding to the emotions that are aroused by uncertainnty and risk. As she she beautifully writes, 
"When I sit with a patient now, deciding on a treatment, I still lay out the risks and benefits as systematically as I can. But then I take a moment to acknowledge the raw fear that cannot be assuaged by even the most convincing clinical data. This conversation can’t eliminate the necessary leap of faith. But at least there is some recognition of the stomach-plummeting sensation that occurs" when a decision has to be made.
Thank, Danielle for your enlightening column! I also highly recommend Dr. Ofri's well written memoirs, including her latest book, What Doctors Feel: How Emotions Affect the Practice of Medicine .

Tuesday, August 27, 2013

EmpathyWorks Has Had 10,000 Views!

On July 11, 2009, I wrote My First Post on EmpathyWorks (click on text to view).

In the 57 posts that have followed, I have shared links and comments about articles, books and research studies on empathy and related aspects of relationship building. Many of my EmpathyWorks posts were links to a column I wrote for MPNforum, an online magazine for people who, like myself, are self-managing, or helping a loved one manage a myeloproliferative neoplasm.

I have enjoyed writing and sharing these tidbits and hope they have provided readers with opportunities to become more aware of the ways in which empathy can be a tool for enhancing understanding and promoting compassion and caring, particularly in health care settings.


I look forward to continuing to continuing to write and reflect on the impact and value of empathy here.

It would be great to have more comments and dialogue with readers, so please feel free to share your thoughts or ideas, either in the comment section on the blog, or via e-mail at goldsteinm52@gmail.com.


Enjoy!

Michael

Saturday, July 20, 2013

Bernie Lown is My Hero

Bernie Lown is my hero and a exemplary role model for physician healers, scientists, and social activists.



As co-founder of International Physicians for the Prevention of Nuclear War, Bernie Lown accepted the Nobel Peace Prize for this organization in 1985. Before that, we was one of the founders of Physicians for Social Responsibility. An accomplished academic cardiologist, he actually has an arrhythmia named after him, the Lown-Ganong-Levine Syndrome. (Please don't ask me to describe it). Bernie is a medical inventor as well. He developed the first direct current defibrillator and still holds an academic position as Professor of Cardiology Emeritus at the Harvard School of Public Health.

For decades, Bernie has been an outspoken critic of the growing medical industrial complex and the business of medicine. He writes eloquently about how these developments contribute to infatuation with and overuse of technology, overtreatment, waste of health care resources, escalating health care expenditures and, most importantly, unnecessary harms to patients.

Now in his 90s, Bernie is still voicing his concerns, as well as encouraging medical practitioners to return to the core values and behaviors that characterized medicine before it became a business. These principles include:
  • listen to your patients and to their "stories";
  • put patients and their needs, values and preferences at the center of your attention;
  • build and nurture healing relationships with patients, using empathy and compassion;  
  • evaluate new and emerging technologies carefully and choose wisely;
  • engage patients and caregivers in informed and shared decision-making; and
  • focus on enabling and empowering patients to help them stay healthy and engage in self-care and self-management.
These principles were the bedrock of good medical care when Bernie, and my dad, completed medical school in the 1940's. I dare say they were core elements of medical training in the days of Flexner and Francis Peabody, when my grandfather trained in the early 20th century. As Francis Peabody remarked in 1927, "One of the essential qualities of the clinician is interest in humanity, for the secret of the care of the patient is the caring for the patient."

Recently, a wonderful interview with Bernie was published on a blog created by Melanie Lown, a communication specialist and Bernie's granddaughter. See: The Lown Conversation.

Melanie is the daughter of Beth Lown, Bernie's daughter, a friend and colleague and a wonderful physician and educator. (See the photo on The Lown Conversation blog of Bernie and 6 year old daughter Beth, taken when Bernie arrived in Boston after accepting the Nobel Peace Prize.)

See also the following sources for more vintage Bernie:

Saturday, November 17, 2012

Empathy Works for Business Too!

See the link below for an article on the value of empathy in the workplace that appeared in the online magazine Smart Business.

The importance of empathy in the workplace | Smart Business

Friday, August 31, 2012

The Empathy Gap - Obama vs. Romney

Empathy, or the lack of it, is an important and perhaps crucial issue in the US Presidential campaign. Results of a CBS News poll released earlier this week shows that half of registered voters think that Mitt Romney does not understand their problems, reflecting an empathy gap with President Obama. See: CBS News Empathy Gap Poll

In an interview that appeared in the online magazine, Slate, noted British author Marin Amis predicts an Obama victory because he sees a “disastrous lack of empathy” in Mitt Romney. See: Slate interview with Martin Amis

Sunday, June 17, 2012

Graphic on Mind the Gap Emphasizes Impact of Clinician-Patient Communication

A new posting on the blog, Mind the Gap, by Stephen Wilkins, graphically shows the value of good clinician-patient communication. See: Mind the Gap Graphic.

I really like the quote he included from George Bernard Shaw, "The problem with communication is the illusion that it has occurred".

Shaw's quote reflects a key finding from research on clinician-patient communication: clinicians who have lover levels of skill are least likely to be aware of their skill deficit. For example, a review on the effectiveness of self-assessment of learner needs by I. Colthart and colleages (Medical Teacher, 30(2):124-45, 2008) found evidence that that the least competent are also the least able to self-assess accurately. This is why we can't count on clinician self-report and need to assess the competency of clinicians using methods that provide direct evidence of clinician communication skills, such as audio or videos of actual encounters,  evaluations of simulated encounters, assessment of patient experience. (See: Levinson et al.,  Health Aff (Millwood) 29(7): 1310-8.)

The good news is that the accuracy of self-assessment can be enhanced by feedback, particularly video and verbal feedback.

Friday, June 15, 2012

Too much talking | QReview

Follow this link Too much talking | QReview to a blog post about the importance of  eliciting understanding, concerns and beliefs and listening, rather than just telling.

The author, Dr. Susan Shaw, is Chair, Health Quality Council and Department Head, Adult Critical Care, for the Saskatoon Health Region in Canada.

The post originally appeared on Q Review, a blog published by theThe Health Quality Council (HQC). HQC is an independent agency that measures and reports on quality of care in Saskatchewan, promotes improvement, and engages its partners in building a better health system.

Friday, May 18, 2012

The Empowered Patient: Hearing is Empowering

My column in the June, 2012 issue of MPNforum, The Empowered Patient: Hearing is Empowering, (http://mpnforum.com/michael-june/ ) is about my long journey to improved hearing. Why did it take me so long to order hearing aids? I hope my story will lower the barriers to obtaining hearing aids among the millions who suffer from age related hearing loss.

Saturday, October 22, 2011

Two Great Links

I have added two new links that I highly recommend:
  • Shared Health Data - a blog and more, written by my friend and colleague, Susan Woods, MD, MPH,  a primary care clinician, researcher and e-health advocate at the Portland, Oregon Veterans Adminstration Medical Center and Oregon Health Sciences University. I referred to Shared Health Data in my previous post about Personal Health Records. Sue describes her blog as follows, "This is a blog about better health and healthcare through exchange of health information, greater transparency and proactive engagement of consumers." It is all that and more. Check out her most recent column which celebrates Steve Jobs's contributions to the transformation of computing into consumer-friendly and empowering applications. She also imagines what Steve Jobs might have created if he worked in healthcare. Click on the link in my favorite sites list or go to http://www.sharedhealthdata.com/
  • Mind the Gap - written by Stephen Wilkins, MPH, a former hospital executive and consumer health behavior researcher who became inspired to focus on patient empowerment as a caregiver for his wife during her successful, and traumatic, experience with cancer.  Mind the Gap offers, "evidence-based insights and best practices for improving patient engagement and the quality of communications between patients and their doctors". Stephen's latest post is entitled, "3 Reasons for Becoming More Patient-Centered". Check out the blog at: http://healthecommunications.wordpress.com/ . It is also on my favorites list.

Saturday, September 17, 2011

New Posting of The Empowered Patient on MPN Forum

The September issue of MPN Forum, an online forum for patients with myeloprolifeative neoplasms. included a column entitled, "Can Clinicians Empower Patients?" and is based on a previous post here.

Enjoy and please comment either here on on the Forum. The link to the column is: http://mpnforum.com/2011/10/12/the-empowered-patient-the-clinicians-role/



Michael

Sunday, June 26, 2011

Questions are the Answer

I have posted the second installment of my column on the MPD Chat listserve below. Though this column is written for members of the myeloproliferative disorders community, my suggestions apply across all conditions. A previoius post on this blog contains similarPlease leave a comment or offer your ideas for questions that patients might ask to enhance their participation in care.
June 23, 2011 – Number 2

The National Patient Safety Foundation's Ask Me 3 campaign (see: http://www.npsf.org/askme3/) encourages patients to ask 3 questions of their health card team to increase their understanding of their health conditions and what to do about them. The 3 questions are:
  1. What is my main problem?
  2. What do I need to do?
  3. Why is it important for me to do this?


Though these questions are good ones, I view the The Ask Me 3 questions as a minimalist approach for promoting clinician-patient communication, patient understanding and enhanced patient capacity to manage their conditions. These questions will help you get your clinicians' view of what you need to know, including their impression of what ails you (e.g., a diagnosis) and the options for managing your condition. Hopefully, if you ask the second question, you will learn not just about treatments, but also self-management options (i.e., what you can do to manage your condition). These questions hopefully will lead to a discussion and not just a lecture.


However, many clinicians do not have the inclination or skill to respond to these basic questions well. So, you may want to bring some additional questions. Here are a few others you might want to consider asking:

  • "What else might be going on to explain my symptoms, examination and test results?" Ask "what else?" at least twice. Dr. Jerome Groopman, the noted oncologist and writer thinks "what else?" is one of THE most important questions you can ask. Asking "what else" actually helps clinicians to reflect and consider possibilities they might have prematurely rejected in their efforts to "make" a diagnoses.
  • "What aspects of my presentation are not well explained by your diagnosis?" "Presentation"" is a word that clinicians use to convey the combination of symptoms, physical examination findings, and lab tests. They will be impressed if you use this word! Again, you are helping them to reflect and consider what doesn't fit their conceptualization.
  • "How sure are you that this is my main problem?"
  • "What tests would help you to be more sure?" For those of us with MPNs, you can get more specific and ask about JAK2 testing, bone marrow biopsies, imaging tests, etc.
  • "How useful would it be to see another doctor who has more experience treating patient with my condition?" This is especially important question for us, since MPNs are relatively uncommon and only those who treat many MPN patients are aware of new and emerging treatments.
  • "What are other treatment options?" This is similar to the "what else could it be?" question in helping the clinician expand his/her thinking about possible treatments.
  • "What are the pros and cons of the treatment options?" Many clinicians minimize the down side - but it is important that you make fully informed choices that include an understanding of the risks and benefits.
  • "What things can I do, (besides taking medication or undergoing other treatments) that will help me to manage my condition and have the best chance of maintaining my function?" Hopefully, this will lead to a discussion of strategies that may enhance your capacity to monitor you condition, maximize your well-being and function (e.g. eating well, being physically active, paciing oneself, etc.)

I realize that it may be challenging to ask ALL of these questions in a single visit...and some clinicians my bristle or balk if you pull out a list or ask too many questions. That kind of reaction is regrettable. After all, this is your life, your health, your condition! The doc may be the expert on the condition and treatment, but you are the expert about you!. Clinicians have the knowledge about what to prescribe. Yet, to effectively manage a condition, especially a MPN, you need to learn how to monitor, manage, cope and adapt.


I hope you will share your own favorite questions here....


Asking is the first step. As the US Agency for Healthcare Research and Qualtiy has said in their ads, "Questions are the Answer!" see: http://www.ahrq.gov/questionsaretheanswer/


Next column, I'll discuss what patients and caregivers can do if their clinician is reluctant to answer questions or hesitant to consider alternative diagnoses, treatments, referrals or self-management education.


Best wishes,
Michael

Sunday, July 19, 2009

My post to the MPD Support Listserve

Below, I have copied and pasted a post I made to a myeloproliferative disorders (MPD) support listserve.

In 2005, I was diagnosed with polycythemia vera, a member of the MPD family of disorders. Like other chronic conditions, these disorders are associated with a variety of symptoms that effect quality of life and function. After my diagnosis, I found the list online and have been a regular reader and contributer since. The MPD Support list provides subscribers with an opportunity to ask questions, share knowledge and experience, learn about the latest research and clinical trials, and share support.

I, personally, have recieved invaluable information and suppoprt from other members of the MPD support list. I have also had an opportunity to offer my perspective as a physician-educator. Quite often, members of the list raise concerns or issues about their interactions with clinicians, especially their clinicians. In response to a post about a particularly problematic interaction witha doc, I shared the following post. Visit the listserve at http://listserv.aol.com/archives/mpd-support-l.html to gain insight into the benefits of such online support groups. See also the resources at the end of the post.

Here is my post from July, 2008:

Unfortunately, all too often, we feel unheard, or even worse, dismissed by physicians who don't understand or value the importance of OUR knowledge, expertise, experience regarding our illness. Docs are not only failing to hear, connect and respond to the needs of patients. As Axxxx pointed out, docs who fail to engage and enlist the patient in care miss, or fail to collect, key information that is essential to diagnosis and treatment planning. This problem not only leads to anger, dissatisfaction and other justifiable responses (such as Exxxx's), it also leads to poor clinical outcomes. As a patient, I have had my own share of problematic interactions with docs. On the other hand, I have had some good experiences as well. As a physician and teacher of other clinicians, my whole career has been dedicated to helping students and clinicians to appreciate the importance of using effective communication. We have a long way to go.... but I have not given up on trying.

So, Exxxx (and others)... we (clinicians)... need to hear you.... respect you... appreciate you.... and acknowledge your expertise... as well as respond to your needs. And we (clinicians) also need to take advantage of listserves like this one, as well as other ways in which patients can assist each other to address the problems and needs associated with having a chronic condition. Cxxxx's advice to bring a family member, or other companion, to health care visits is a wonderful idea. It helps to have another set of ears, and an advocate with us to increase the chances that we (patients) will be get needs met and questions addressed.

I have found a couple of wonderful organizations and programs that are striving to enhance patients' capacity to manage their health conditions, as well as their engagement in the process of improving care. See the websites for the Institute for Family Centered Care (www. familycenteredcare. org (http://www.familycenteredcare.org)) and New Health Partnerships (www.newhealthpartnerships.org (http://www.newhealthpartnerships.org)). I have had the pleasure of working closely with both of these organizations and can vouch for their value to patients, clinicians and health care systems. You will find lots of good resources. [Rxxxx.. there may be some ways that we can create links to these sites from our websites].I would love to have the opportunity to serve as a source of support of members of this list who would like help forging effective partnerships with their health care providers. However, the best advice will come not from me, but from other members of this community who can share the strategies that have worked for them. Feel free however to write to me on the list as well as offline (goldsteinm@aol.com)

Michael PV since 1/2006, asa, phlebotomy

Saturday, July 18, 2009

Comment to a Paulene Chen Column

The post below was originally made on a NYT Blog, "Do Doctors Have Time for Empathy?" (http://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2008/09/25/do-doctors-have-time-for-empathy/)
that was linked to a column written by Paulene Chen, MD. Dr. Chen, a transplant surgeon, has a wonderful column, Doctor and Patient, that appears regularly in the NYT. The original column was entitled, Taking Time for Empathy, http://www.nytimes.com/2008/09/26/health/chen25.html

I recommend reading Dr. Chen's columns, as well as the comments available for each column. See also the links listed at the end of my post.

Here is the post:

I hope this does not sound self-serving. My entire professional life as a physican, teacher, researcher, consultant has been devoted to promoting empathy and patient and family-centered care within the context of clinician-patient interactions. I am passionate about empathy.
So, soon after getting an e-mail with a link to Dr. Chen’s moving column, I eagerly read every word of every comment listed here. I found myself resonating with many comments….especially by those of you who were willing to share their stories about their experience as patients and family members.

As Drs. Back, Chen and others have noted in their comments, there is now a growing body of research indicating that empathy matters. Clinician empathy is associated with a range of outcomes including not only patient satisfaction and trust, but also follow-through with medical recommendations and improved health care status.

There is also a growing evidence base indicating that empathy can indeed by taught, at any level, even years after completing professional training. Training is necessary but not sufficient. Even though most schools have courses in clinician-patient communication - I used to help run one - the “hidden curriculum, which refers to negative role-modeling from less enlightened faculty can undermine more formal educational opportunities. As several physicians have mentioned on in this thread, it was the example of their mentors that had the most lasting impression on them. We need more caring, empathic medical faculty (like Drs. Back and Chen) who walk the walk, as well as talk the talk.

I could go on…but I rather read what you all are writing. Thanks so much for this opportunity to read and respond.

BTW, if anyone wants to learn about efforts to teach empathy and other core communication skills to health care professionals see: http://www.healthcarecomm.org/ and http://www.aachonline.org/.

Michael Goldstein
From Pauline Chen: Thank you, Dr. Goldstein, for all your important and hopeful work in this area and for including those links.— Michael Goldstein

Saturday, July 11, 2009

My First Post

With much trepidation, I write this first post to my own blog. I have to admit that, though I have been hesitant to create a blog, I have secretly wanted to have a public space to share my views.

For a long time, I have been been a passionate advocate for patient and family-centered health care and have spent the last 25 years trying to learn, and teach, skills that foster strong clinician-patient relationships. I have been very fortunate to have had many wonderful teachers, mentors, colleagues and patients who have helped me along the way. Though I believe I have become a pretty decent communicator, and some might say a very good teacher, I am humble enough to realize that I still have a lot to learn

In my efforts to enhance my own skills as a clinician and educator, I have hungrily sought out training, scoured the clinician-patient communication research literature, conducted some research myself and experimented with a variety of teaching techniques and formats. Relatively early on in my personal journey as a clinician-educator, I realized that the most basic skills were also the most important. If we can't communicate well, can't connect with patients on a personal level, can't understand the patient's concerns, how can we hope to help them heal, cope and recover?

The most basic skills are linked to what my colleagues and friends Steven Cole and Julian Bird have call the 3 functions, or tasks, of the clinician-patient encounter (which I have adapted a bit):
  1. Eliciting the patient's story/problems/concerns/needs
  2. Building a strong clinician-patient relationship
  3. Developing a shared understanding of the problem/condition and collaborating on a plan for treatment and self-management

Each of these tasks can be accomplished though the use of specific skills....a long list of skills i might add, though some are more basic than others.

Empathy, in my humble opinion, is THE most important and powerful skill that clinicians can employ to enhance communication and forge strong healing relationships with patients and families. Empathy helps us to truly understand the experience of patients so we can ultimately help them. Through empathy, we strive to "stand in another's shoes" and see the world through their eyes. To be truly empathic this requires us to maintain an open heart and an open mind. This is not easy....and requires clinicians to be willing to spend the time it takes to understand, remain relentlessly curious and suspend all judgement. However, the payoff is immense....shared understanding, stronger relationships, and even better diagnosis and treatment outcomes.

So, I continue striving...and learning...and sharing...now here as well.

Michael