Showing posts with label caring. Show all posts
Showing posts with label caring. Show all posts

Monday, June 22, 2015

For Empathy!

As a follow-up to a previous blog post, Against Empathy? , I would like to share a column by Denise Cummins, PhD, a cognitive scientist and author. Dr. Cummins is an elected Fellow of the Association for Psychological Science and her research specialty is decision-making and thinking.

In her column, which appeared in Psychology Today in 2013, Cummins argues that Bloom is wrong when he concludes "empathy is prone to biases that render moral judgment potentially harmful.” 

 As Cummins points out in her column, Bloom errs when he posits that empathy for the suffering of individual victims that we can identify with because they are "like us" produces biased and faulty moral reasoning that can lead to mass retribution and violence.

Cummins argues that Bloom places too much value on reasoning, which is certainly not immune from faulty  moral judgements. Cummins suggests that it is the pairing of empathy with "good" reasoning that leads to humanitarian actions.

"The answer is to expand our empathy to include those who are not like us. That is what drove so many white Americans to argue for the abolition of slavery, the end of Jim Crow laws, and the institution of civil rights.......It is precisely our ability to imagine the plight of the nameless and faceless that elicits our empathy and our desire to act."

Dr. Cummins ends her column with the following call for embracing both our capacity for empathy and our ability to reason when engaging in moral reasoning.

"Instead, it is the marriage of empathy to principle that has always been and will continue to be our salvation. It is our ability to generalize and to direct our empathy through the use of reason that is our saving grace. Without that, it is easy to create a holocaust, a crusade, or a jihad.

More on Dr. Cummins' illuminating views on the value of empathy can be found  on the Culture of Empathy website.

Dr. Cummins wrote Good Thinking: Seven Powerful Ideas that Influence the Way We Think (Cambridge University Press, 2012).

Friday, August 1, 2014

Learning and Practicing Spiritual Empathy

Follow the link below to a moving post is by an Israeli rabbinical student intern who is completing an internship as a hospital chaplain. He shares his struggles to comprehend, connect with and ease the suffering of patients, a challenge that is even more difficult in the setting of the current Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/avram-mlotek/spiritual-empathy_b_5619383.html

Saturday, December 28, 2013

A Short Video on Empathy Featuring Brené Brown


Sue Raffa, PhD, a colleague at Alpert Medical School, Brown University,  recently shared a wonderful animated video on empathy with me. The brief video was created by the Royal Society of the Arts (RSA) and features Brene Brown, PhD, LMSW, a research professor at the University of Houston Graduate Colleage of Social Work.

You can find the video at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1Evwgu369Jw

The video offers a wonderful, quick,and amusing lesson on empathy and how if differs from sympathy. 

I particularly like Dr. Brown's  reference to the 4 key qualities of empathy:

  1. perspective taking
  2. staying out of judgement
  3. recognizing emotion; and
  4. communicating what you notice


I also like her idea that empathy "fuels connection", contrasted with sympathy, which "drives disconnection". Empathy, she states, can be operationalized as "feeling with" other and requires a "vulnerable choice". She adds, "To connect with you, I have to connect with something in myself that knows that feeling", which can be painful. Empathy, she notes, is not about trying to make things better, it's about being present and expressing understanding to a person who is struggling>

"Rarely can a response make something better....what makes something better is connection."

Awesome! 

Sunday, October 6, 2013

Rachel Remen, The Healer's Art, and Healing Healers

Two recent columns in the New York Times by David Bornstein highlight the work of Rachel Remen, MD, a physician, healer, educator and writer whom I deeply admire and respect.

David Bornstein is a journalist who has chronicled the impact of social entrepreneurs (I love his book, How to Change the World).  David writes a blog for NYT called "Fixes". In his September 18, 2013 column, Medicine's Search for Meaning, he writes about burnout among physicians that results from the challenges of practicing medicine in the current environment, one that focuses on productivity and treatment outcomes, rather than on meeting the emotional and functional needs of patients. To paraphrase:
"....healing involves far more than knowledge and skill. The process by which a doctor helps a patient accept, recover from, adapt to, or endure a serious illness is full of nuance and mystery......Great doctors don’t just diagnose diseases, prescribe medications and treat patients; they bring the full spectrum of their human capabilities to the compassionate care of others....."
Bornstein also writes:
"As administrative and documentation burdens have exploded in the past three decades, doctors find themselves under pressures to work as quickly as possible. Many have found that what is sacrificed is the very thing that gives meaning to the whole undertaking: the patient-doctor relationship."
Bornstein quotes medical educators who note that these burdens produce high levels of distress, depression, loss of satisfaction, fatigue, and burnout, producing "medical errors, substance abuse, and doctors quitting" and asks,  "How could we help medicine overcome its own illness?"

Bornstein answers his own question by describing work of Rachel Remen, who, as I noted in my introduction, has been a source of inspiration and healing for me for many years. Rachel is a wonderful clinician, educator and writer who has dedicated her career to meeting the broad biopsychosocial and spiritual needs of her patients. Through her writings and trainings, she has also helped practicing clinicians, as well as clinicians in training, to recapture the core values...the "meaning" ... that often led them to choose medicine or nursing as a career.

The Healer’s Art course was developed by Rachel over 2 decades ago at the University of California, San Francisco medical school. As David writes, The Healer's Art:
"is predicated on the idea that medicine is an ancient lineage that draws its strength from its core values: compassion, service, reverence for life and harmlessness. When students  derive meaning and strength .....[from these values, they] can 'immunize' themselves against the assaults of the medical curriculum and even the health care system itself."
The Healer's Art has now spread to dozen's of medical and nursing schools in the US and to a growing list of professional schools around the globe.

A similar program for practicing clinicians,  Finding Meaning in Medicine (FMM), provides a supportive forum for exploring core values and sharing positive experiences related to working with patients. I was a member of a FMM group for a few years and found it highly enlightening, rewarding and satisfying. Though I left the group when I changed jobs, I am still longing for participating in a group years later.

There were so many poignant and heartfelt responses by clinicians to the Sept 18th column that David wrote a follow-up column, Who Will Heal the Doctors?. This produced even more responses, reflecting the need for more programs like The Healer's Art and FMM.
As I noted in my comment, my heart goes out to all my colleagues who continue to make daily sacrifices to care for their patients, providing every ounce of compassion they can in the few minutes they have with patients.
I have been planning to attend the Healer's Art training program at Commonweal for several years now so I might serve as a facilitator of the program at Brown University's medical school. Just yesterday, I made a commitment to apply to attend the 2014 course, with Rachel, at The Institute for the Study of Health & Illness (ISHI). I am already excited about attending and experiencing some healing myself.

See more on Rachel, The Healer's Art, FMM and ISHI at:
www.rachelremen.com 
www.ishiprograms.org
www.theheartofmedicine.org

Tuesday, August 27, 2013

EmpathyWorks Has Had 10,000 Views!

On July 11, 2009, I wrote My First Post on EmpathyWorks (click on text to view).

In the 57 posts that have followed, I have shared links and comments about articles, books and research studies on empathy and related aspects of relationship building. Many of my EmpathyWorks posts were links to a column I wrote for MPNforum, an online magazine for people who, like myself, are self-managing, or helping a loved one manage a myeloproliferative neoplasm.

I have enjoyed writing and sharing these tidbits and hope they have provided readers with opportunities to become more aware of the ways in which empathy can be a tool for enhancing understanding and promoting compassion and caring, particularly in health care settings.


I look forward to continuing to continuing to write and reflect on the impact and value of empathy here.

It would be great to have more comments and dialogue with readers, so please feel free to share your thoughts or ideas, either in the comment section on the blog, or via e-mail at goldsteinm52@gmail.com.


Enjoy!

Michael

Sunday, March 24, 2013

Watch this Wonderful Video: "Empathy: The Human Connection to Patient Care"

Empathy is an essential element of quality health care. This video (Empathy: The Human Connection to Patient Care) simply, and beautifully, illustrates the value of seeking to understand others' experience. Listening, noticing, exploring and responding helps us to build healing connections with patients, family members and  caregivers. Empathy also helps those of us who are privileged to work in health care settings to know and support each other.

The video was published on YouTube on February 27, 2013 with the following information:
Patient care is more than just healing -- it's building a connection that encompasses mind, body and soul.

If you could stand in someone else's shoes . . . hear what they hear. See what they see. Feel what they feel. Would you treat them differently?

CEO Toby Cosgrove, MD, shared this video, titled "Empathy," with the Cleveland Clinic staff during his 2012 State of the Clinic address on Feb. 27, 2013.
 

Saturday, December 29, 2012

New Research Suggests Empathy and Analytic Thinking are Mutually Exclusive

Recent research utilizing functional MRI suggests that the circuits of the brain that are activated during analytic tasks are actually inhibited when people are engaged in social tasks,  and vice versa.

So, for example, when people are engaged in tasks that stimulate the centers of the brain associated with analytic problem solving, pathways activated during tasks that evoke empathic understanding are inhibited. The results, published online in the neuroimaging journal, NeuroImage, in October, 2012, were  summarized in an artilce that appeared on Medical News Today  - http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/252241.php

These interesting findings shed light on the neural processes invovled in analytic and social tasks and suggest that empathic thinking and analytic thinking may be mutually exclusive. No wonder it is hard for us to consider the experience and feelings of others when we are deeply engaged in analytic problem solving. This also may explain why many health care providers miss opportunities to respond to patients' emotions when they are "conducting a history" and engaging in diagnostic reasoning and treatment planning.

From a healthcare professional training perspective, these research findings suggest that clinicians need to learn how to compensate for the inhibition of the social circuitry that occurs when they enage in analytic tasks. Helping clinicians to actively "tune in" to patients' emotional state may help "turn down" their analytic thinking and allow them to respond more effectively to patients' psychosocial needs.

Saturday, November 17, 2012

Empathy Works for Business Too!

See the link below for an article on the value of empathy in the workplace that appeared in the online magazine Smart Business.

The importance of empathy in the workplace | Smart Business

Wednesday, September 5, 2012

More on the Empathy Gap in the Race for the White House

This article in Salon covering Michele Obama's speech at the Democratic National Convention provides another take on the emapthy gap between the major US political Parties:

Republicans’ empathy gap

Monday, April 16, 2012

Strategy #6 for Empowerment - Connect with Others

See the 1 year anniversary issue of MPNforum for my latest The Empowered Patient column: http://mpnforum.com/the-empowered-patient-connect-with-others/

MPNforum is an online magazine that features news, interviews and stories on topics of interest to people with Myeloproliferative Neoplasms. My contribution to the May, 2012 issue focuses on the benefits of connecting with others through online magazines, support pages and listserves. Experiencing and expressing empathy are among the most valuable aspects of contributing to and participating in these online resources and sites.

Saturday, October 15, 2011

Personal Health Records: Another Path to Empowerment

In my latest column in the October issue of MPN (Myeloproliferative Neoplasms) Forum, I share ways in which I have used a Personal Health Record (PHR) to track information about my condition. Using the tools available in PHRs, I can create graphs that show the relationship between treatments and key lab values. Sharing these graphs with my physicians not only helps us to make better decisions about my treatment, it also saves time and allows us to focus on what's important to me, including my feelings and concerns about my condition. My doctors have been very receptive to my use of these tools, and I have benefitted from the increased time they havefor empathy!

See link to the column in MPN Forum below:

http://mpnforum.com/a-oct-michael/

Note: the link is no longer working, so here is a version of the article:


The Empowered Patient – MPN Forum

October, 2011 – Draft 3

Personal Health Records: Another Path to Empowerment

 

Just this week, I prepared for my PV follow-up visit with my oncologist by printing out computer-generated graphs of my cbc results over the last 5 years. The graphs included labels indicating when I had started and stopped HU and made changes to my dose of interferon. See below for one of the graphs I brought with me to the visit.

 

 


 

Using this handy graphical representation of my response to treatment, both my oncologist and I were able to "see" where I was in my treatment. As a physician myself, I have an advantage, as I have more understanding than a typical patient about the meaning of blood tests and medical events. Also, my oncologist, who is on the Brown Medical School faculty, knew me as a colleague for many years before I became his patient. We respect each other’s expertise, and once I became a patient, we had long conversations about my PV and its likely course and prognosis. I bring him articles and share the latest findings from hematology/oncology meetings, which he appreciates. He once remarked that he should get continuing medical educational credits for my visits with him!

 

As a physician, it has always been important for me to feel prepared so I was making the most informed decisions with my patients. This need for preparation has carried over to how I approach the management of my own condition. Having reviewed the graphs the night before, I was prepared to remind my doctor that we had started Pegasys 2 years ago, and that we had made the last dose adjustment in May. We looked at the graphs together, which showed that my PV remission, initially achieved with high doses of Pegasys, has been maintained as I have gradually reduced my weekly dose. The time we saved by not having to search through my chart for the dates and data was devoted to discussing my symptoms, feelings and my preferences for treatment. We agreed to continue a slow taper of Pegasys and to recheck my JAK2 allele burden once i completed 6 months at my current dose. My oncologist marveled at my quite rudimentary spreadsheet, created from an online Personal Health Record (PHR) program. He asked me if he could make a copy of the graphs to scan into my chart, remarking, "I wish all my patients brought in graphs like these!" The good news is that we all can! And, there is evidence that if we monitor and track our own medical data, we can improve the quality and safety of our care.

 

In previous columns, I have focused on strategies that we, as patients, can use to help us get the most out of our visits with our doctors and other members of our health care team.  Preparing for clinic visits, asking questions, sharing concerns, and being assertive about our needs are strategies that can help us to take a more active role in decisions about our care, and can help us to learn to cope with and manage our conditions. This is one path to empowerment, one that takes advantage of interactions with members of our health care team. Yet, many of us see our doctors only a few times a year, and there may be only a few minutes available for us to use these strategies, even if our doctor obliges. Thankfully, PHRs are available to help us take a more active role in our care.

 

PHRs are health records that are designed to be used by patients, in contrast to medical records created by doctors, hospitals or clinics to keep track of and document our health history and care. I'm sure most of you have seen at least snippets of your doctor's chart notes or an oncologist's consultation note, or perhaps a lab or x-ray report. These medical records are full of highly technical language and obscure abbreviations that only a health care professional can fully understand. Before the advent of electronic health records (EHRs), many were illegible, too!  Because these "clinician-facing" records are not understandable to most of us, they have limited utility for helping us to manage our conditions. As an example, I recently got a copy of my eye exam after developing some new visual symptoms. Despite being a doctor and also the son of an eye doctor, I couldn’t understand all the notations and abbreviations used to document the findings from my exam! And, unless you currently get your care in a very forward thinking health care organization, these medical records usually don't provide graphs like the one I created myself. They are even less likely to include the information that may be most meaningful to you, like the names and contact information of key people in your lives, your use of non-traditional forms of healing, or your health care preferences. And they are even less likely to mention your life goals and values (e.g., what's really, really, important to you) or your ideas for optimizing your health (e.g., engaging in more physical activity; spending time with grandkids).  PHRs, because they are designed for you, often include this information, and more!

Typically, PHRs help you to keep track of key health information, including data about your:

•   allergies and adverse drug reactions;

•   chronic conditions (including your MPN);

•   family history;

•   illnesses and hospitalizations;

•   laboratory test results, imaging reports (e.g. x-ray), pathology reports (e.g., bone marrow biopsy results);

•   immunization records and records of preventive screening tests (e.g., mammography results);

•   medications and dosing, including over the counter medications and herbal remedies; and

•   surgeries and other procedures.

 

Having all of this information available to share with new providers, or in emergencies, is invaluable and can reduce medical errors that result from depending on our memory at a time when we are ill or stressed. Simply have this historical data in an easily accessible form can be empowering, both to us and our health care team.

 

Some PHRs, particularly electronic versions, go a lot further than just storing key health information and data. These advanced PHRs are interactive and provide electronic links to relevant health information, offer tools and resources for self-management, warn you about potential drug-drug interactions, remind you to obtain medication refills and obtain needed tests, and allow you to make appointments with your providers. Some even provide you with access to your providers through secure electronic messaging, a form of email that protects your privacy, allowing you to ask questions of your health care team or report concerns directly to them. Being able to communicate with your health care team between face-to-face visits and outside of the limitations of telephone calls is freeing and, in systems that embrace this approach to communication, increases the chances that you can get the information you need in a timely way. Now that's empowering!

 

A colleague and friend, Susan Woods, MD, works in the area of Medical Informatics, en emerging new field that focuses on using information technology to enhance the quality of medical care. Sue has a blog called Shared Health Data http://www.sharedhealthdata.com/ that I highly recommend as a source of news and developments in this rapidly growing field. Several columns on her blog focus on PHRs and other "patient-facing" medical informatics tools.

For an example of a PHR that you can complete online and download, see  http://howsyourhealth.com/. This site, which was developed by health care professionals at Dartmouth Medical School, uses questions and assessments to gather data about your history, symptoms and function and then provides you with feedback and links to resources. Some health care plans and communities allow you to share your howsyourhealth record with your providers. Other online PHRs and related tools are available through Microsoft HealthVault at http://www.microsoft.com/en-us/healthvault/.

 

I am curious to know how members of our MPN community are utilizing PHRs and related tools. Please share your experiences, ideas and comments here.

Saturday, July 18, 2009

Comment to a Paulene Chen Column

The post below was originally made on a NYT Blog, "Do Doctors Have Time for Empathy?" (http://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2008/09/25/do-doctors-have-time-for-empathy/)
that was linked to a column written by Paulene Chen, MD. Dr. Chen, a transplant surgeon, has a wonderful column, Doctor and Patient, that appears regularly in the NYT. The original column was entitled, Taking Time for Empathy, http://www.nytimes.com/2008/09/26/health/chen25.html

I recommend reading Dr. Chen's columns, as well as the comments available for each column. See also the links listed at the end of my post.

Here is the post:

I hope this does not sound self-serving. My entire professional life as a physican, teacher, researcher, consultant has been devoted to promoting empathy and patient and family-centered care within the context of clinician-patient interactions. I am passionate about empathy.
So, soon after getting an e-mail with a link to Dr. Chen’s moving column, I eagerly read every word of every comment listed here. I found myself resonating with many comments….especially by those of you who were willing to share their stories about their experience as patients and family members.

As Drs. Back, Chen and others have noted in their comments, there is now a growing body of research indicating that empathy matters. Clinician empathy is associated with a range of outcomes including not only patient satisfaction and trust, but also follow-through with medical recommendations and improved health care status.

There is also a growing evidence base indicating that empathy can indeed by taught, at any level, even years after completing professional training. Training is necessary but not sufficient. Even though most schools have courses in clinician-patient communication - I used to help run one - the “hidden curriculum, which refers to negative role-modeling from less enlightened faculty can undermine more formal educational opportunities. As several physicians have mentioned on in this thread, it was the example of their mentors that had the most lasting impression on them. We need more caring, empathic medical faculty (like Drs. Back and Chen) who walk the walk, as well as talk the talk.

I could go on…but I rather read what you all are writing. Thanks so much for this opportunity to read and respond.

BTW, if anyone wants to learn about efforts to teach empathy and other core communication skills to health care professionals see: http://www.healthcarecomm.org/ and http://www.aachonline.org/.

Michael Goldstein
From Pauline Chen: Thank you, Dr. Goldstein, for all your important and hopeful work in this area and for including those links.— Michael Goldstein